| Year | Name | Team | Pos. |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1959 | Brandon Glover | Third | 130 lbs. |
| 1994 | Josh Feldman | Seventh | HWT |
| 2000 | Sean Gray | Seventh | 141 lbs. |
| 2000 | Chris Martin | Fourth | 165 lbs. |
| 2001 | Sean Gray | Sixth | 141 lbs. |
| 2006 | Mike Faust | Fifth | HWT |
| 2006 | David Hoffman | Eighth | 141 lbs. |
| 2010 | Chris Diaz | Eighth | 141 lbs. |
| 2012 | Devin Carter | Fifth | 133 lbs. |
| 2012 | Pete Yates | Fifth | 165 lbs. |
| 2013 | Nick Brascetta | Eighth | 149 lbs. |
| 2013 | Jarrod Garnett | Sixth | 125 lbs. |
| 2013 | Zach Neibert | Eighth | 141 lbs. |
| 2013 | Pete Yates | Fourth | 165 lbs. |
| 2014 | Devin Carter | Second | 141 lbs. |
| 2014 | Joey Dance | Fourth | 125 lbs. |
| 2014 | Chris Penny | Sixth | 197 lbs. |
| 2015 | Nick Brascetta | Fourth | 157 lbs. |
| 2015 | Devin Carter | Third | 141 lbs. |
| 2015 | Zach Epperly | Seventh | 174 lbs. |
| 2015 | Ty Walz | Seventh | HWT |
| 2016 | Nick Brascetta | Third | 157 lbs. |
| 2016 | Solomon Chishko | Sixth | 141 lbs. |
| 2016 | Zach Epperly | Third | 174 lbs. |
| 2016 | Jared Haught | Sixth | 197 lbs. |
| 2016 | David McFadden | Sixth | 165 lbs. |
| 2016 | Ty Walz | Fourth | HWT |
| 2017 | Solomon Chishko | Sixth | 149 lbs. |
| 2017 | Joey Dance | Fifth | 125 lbs. |
| 2017 | Jared Haught | Fourth | 197 lbs. |
| 2017 | Sal Mastriani | Eighth | 157 lbs. |
| 2017 | Ty Walz | Fourth | HWT |
| 2018 | Jared Haught | Second | 197 lbs. |
| 2018 | David McFadden | Fifth | 165 lbs. |
| 2018 | Zack Zavatsky | Sixth | 184 lbs. |
| 2019 | Mekhi Lewis | First | 165 lbs. |
| 2019 | David McFadden | Fifth | 174 lbs. |
| 2019 | Zack Zavatsky | Eighth | 184 lbs. |
| 2020* | David McFadden | 165 lbs. | |
| 2020* | Hunter Bolen | 184 lbs. | |
| 2021 | Korbin Myers | Fourth | 133 lbs. |
| 2021 | Sam Latona | Sixth | 125 lbs. |
| 2021 | Hunter Bolen | Seventh | 184 lbs. |
Wrestling: The top eight places in each event at the NCAA Championship are awarded All-American.
(*) — chosen by NWCA after 2020 NCAA Championships were canceled.
Academic All-Americans
As selected by CoSIDA
| Year | Name | Team | Pos. |
|---|---|---|---|
| 2006 | Mike Faust | 3rd | Men's At-Large |
| 2014 | Devin Carter | 2nd | Men's At-Large |
| 2015 | Devin Carter | 1st | Men's At-Large |
U - Unanimous Selection
C - Consensus Selection
Y - Academic All-American of the Year