Athletic All-Americans
| Year | Name | Team | Pos. |
|---|---|---|---|
| 1981 | Tracy Deely | ||
| 1981 | Lori McKee Taylor | ||
| 1982 | Steve Hetherington | ||
| 1987 | Steve Taylor | ||
| 1987 | Tony Williams | ||
| 1989 | Brian Walter | ||
| 2003 | Marlies Overbeeke | ||
| 2007 | Tasmin Fanning | ||
| 2008 | Tasmin Fanning | ||
| 2011 | Will Mulherin | ||
| 2012 | Will Mulherin | ||
| 2015 | Thomas Curtin | ||
| 2018 | Peter Seufer | ||
| 2019 | Peter Seufer |
Academic All-Americans
As selected by CoSIDA
| Year | Name | Team | Pos. |
|---|---|---|---|
| 2004 | Marlies Overbeeke | 2nd | |
| 2010 | Matej Muza | 2nd | |
| 2010 | Kelly Phillips | 3rd | |
| 2012 | Francis Dowd | 1st | |
| 2012 | Alexander Ziegler | 2nd | |
| 2013 | Alexander Ziegler | 1st | |
| 2018 | Vincent Ciattei | 2nd |
U - Unanimous Selection
C - Consensus Selection
Y - Academic All-American of the Year