Four-Time NCAA All-American
Mekhi Lewis - 1 (165, 2019), 2 (174, 2022), 4 (174, 2023), 4 (174, 2024)
Three-Time NCAA All-Americans
Caleb Henson - 5 (149, 2023), 1 (149, 2024), 2 (149, 2025)
Bryce Andonian - 3 (149, 2022), 7 (157, 2023), 6 (157, 2024)
David McFadden - 6 (165, 2016), 5 (165, 2018), 5 (174, 2019), NWCA All-American (2020)
Jared Haught - 6 (197, 2016), 4 (197, 2017), 2 (197, 2018)
Ty Walz - 7 (HWT, 2015), 4 (HWT, 2016), 4 (HWT, 2017)
Nick Brascetta - 8 (149, 2013), 4 (157, 2015), 3 (157, 2016)
Devin Carter - 5 (133, 2012), 2 (141, 2014), 3 (141, 2015)
Two-Time NCAA All-Americans
Eddie Ventresca - 7 (125, 2023), 5 (125, 2025)
Sam Latona - 6 (125, 2021), 7 (133, 2023)
Korbin Myers - 4 (133, 2021), 6 (133, 2022)
Zack Zavatsky - 6 (184, 2018), 8 (184, 2019)
Solomon Chishko - 6 (141, 2016), 6 (149, 2017)
Zach Epperly - 7 (174, 2015), 3 (174, 2016)
Joey Dance - 4 (125, 2014), 5 (125, 2017)
Pete Yates - 5 (165, 2012), 4 (165, 2013)
Sean Gray - 7 (141, 2000), 6 (141, 2001)
NCAA All-Americans
Connor McGonagle - 7 (133, 2025)
TJ Stewart - 7 (184, 2024)
Hunter Bolen - NWCA All-American (2020), 7 (184, 2021)
Sal Mastriani - 8 (157, 2017)
Chris Penny - 6 (197, 2014)
Zach Neibert - 8 (141, 2013)
Jarrod Garnett - 6 (125, 2013)
Chris Diaz - 8 (141, 2011)
Mike Faust - 5 (HWT, 2006)
David Hoffman - 8 (141, 2006)
Chris Martin - 4 (165, 2000)
Josh Feldman - 7 (HWT, 1994)
Brandon Glover - 3 (130, 1959)