| Year | Name | Sport | Team | Pos. |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1958 | Carroll Dale | Football | 2nd | End |
| 1959 | Carroll Dale | Football | 1st | End |
| 1959 | Brandon Glover | Wrestling | 3rd Place | 130 lbs. |
| 1960 | Chris Smith | Men's Basketball | HM | Center |
| 1962 | Bucky Keller | Men's Basketball | HM | Forward |
| 1962 | Howard Pardue | Men's Basketball | HM | Forward |
| 1963 | Bob Schweickert | Football | 3rd | Quarterback |
| 1964 | Bob Schweickert | Football | 1st | Quarterback |
| 1965 | Tim Collins | Men's Golf | 3rd | |
| 1966 | George Foussekis | Football | 2nd | Defensive End |
| 1966 | Frank Loria | Football | 1st | Safety |
| 1967 | Tim Collins | Men's Golf | 2nd | |
| 1967 | Frank Loria C | Football | 1st | Safety |
| 1968 | Mike Widger | Football | 1st | Linebacker |
| 1972 | Don Strock | Football | 3rd | Quarterback |
| 1976 | Keith Neff | Track & Field | Indoor | Pole Vault |
| 1978 | Dennis Scott | Track & Field | Indoor | 60 |
| 1980 | Ray Ackenbom | Track & Field | Indoor | Two-mile relay |
| 1980 | Mike Burns | Track & Field | Indoor | Two-mile relay |
| 1980 | John Dyer | Track & Field | Outdoor | Decathlon |
| 1980 | Lucy Hawk Banks | Track & Field | Outdoor | 800 |
| 1980 | Kenny Lewis | Track & Field | Indoor | 55m High Hurdles |
| 1980 | Ray McDaniels | Track & Field | Indoor | 2-mile relay |
| 1980 | Bruce Merritt | Track & Field | Indoor | 2-mile relay |
| 1980 | Bob Phillips | Track & Field | Outdoor | Pole Vault |
| 1981 | Robert Brown | Football | 2nd | Defensive End |
| 1981 | Tracy Deely | Cross Country | ||
| 1981 | Lori McKee Taylor | Cross Country | ||
| 1981 | Franklin Stubbs | Baseball | 1st | First Base |
| 1981 | Paul Sulik | Track & Field | Outdoor | Hammer Throw |
| 1981 | Judy Williams | Track & Field | Outdoor | 10,000 |
| 1982 | Steve Hetherington | Cross Country | ||
| 1982 | Lori McKee Taylor | Track & Field | Outdoor | 3,000 |
| 1982 | Jim Stewart | Baseball | 1st | Third Base |
| 1982 | Franklin Stubbs | Baseball | 1st | First Base |
| 1983 | Bruce Smith | Football | 1st | Defensive Tackler |
| 1984 | Linda King | Track & Field | Outdoor | 10,000 |
| 1984 | Bruce Smith C | Football | 1st | Defensive Tackle |
| 1985 | Linda King | Track & Field | Outdoor | 10,000 |
| 1985 | Mark Stickley | Track & Field | Outdoor | 10,000 |
| 1986 | George Canale | Baseball | 1st | First Base |
| 1986 | Dell Curry | Men's Basketball | 1st | Guard |
| 1986 | Chris Kinzer | Football | 2nd | Placekicker |
| 1987 | Gary Cobb | Track & Field | Indoor | 1,000 |
| 1987 | Gary Cobb | Track & Field | Outdoor | 1,500 |
| 1987 | Margarita Lasaga | Track & Field | Outdoor | 10,000 |
| 1987 | Trey McCoy | Baseball | 3rd | Left Field |
| 1987 | Phil Saunders | Track & Field | Outdoor | Triple Jump |
| 1987 | Steve Taylor | Track & Field | Outdoor | 10,000 |
| 1987 | Steve Taylor | Cross Country | ||
| 1987 | Tony Williams | Track & Field | Outdoor | 10,000 |
| 1987 | Tony Williams | Cross Country | ||
| 1989 | Margaret Soulen | Swimming & Diving | HM | 100 Backstroke |
| 1989 | Margaret Soulen | Swimming & Diving | HM | 200 Backstroke |
| 1989 | Brian Walter | Cross Country | ||
| 1990 | Bimbo Coles | Men's Basketball | HM | Guard |
| 1991 | Eugene Chung | Football | 1st | Offensive Tackle |
| 1992 | Mike Sergent | Track & Field | Outdoor | Hammer Throw |
| 1993 | Dee Dalton | Baseball | 3rd | Shortstop |
| 1993 | Jim Pyne U | Football | 1st | Center |
| 1994 | Josh Feldman | Wrestling | 7th Place | 275 lbs. |
| 1995 | Cornell Brown C | Football | 1st | Defensive End |
| 1995 | J.C. Price | Football | 3rd | Defensive Tackle |
| 1995 | Jenny Root | Women's Basketball | HM | Center |
| 1996 | Kevin Barker | Baseball | 2nd | Outfield |
| 1996 | Cornell Brown | Football | 1st | Defensive End |
| 1996 | Billy Conaty | Football | 1st | Center |
| 1996 | Charlie Gillian | Baseball | 3rd | Pitcher |
| 1996 | Oliver Mayo | Men's Tennis | ||
| 1997 | Matt Griswold | Baseball | 3rd | Outfield |
| 1997 | Pierson Prioleau | Football | 3rd | Rover |
| 1998 | Erick Kingston | Track & Field | Outdoor | Hammer Throw |
| 1998 | Corey Moore | Football | 1st | Defensive End |
| 1998 | Katie Ollendick | Track & Field | Indoor | High Jump |
| 1998 | Katie Ollendick | Track & Field | Outdoor | Heptathlon |
| 1998 | Derek Smith | Football | 3rd | Offensive Tackle |
| 1999 | Larry Bowles | Baseball | 3rd | Pitcher/First Base |
| 1999 | John Engelberger | Football | 2nd | Defensive End |
| 1999 | Barry Gauch | Baseball | 3rd | Catcher |
| 1999 | Aaron Marchetti | Men's Tennis | ||
| 1999 | Anthony Midget | Football | 3rd | Cornerback |
| 1999 | Corey Moore U | Football | 1st | Defensive End |
| 1999 | Jamel Smith | Football | 2nd | Linebacker |
| 1999 | Michael Vick | Football | 1st | Quarterback |
| 1999 | Dawn Will | Lacrosse | HM | MF |
| 1999 | Tere Williams | Women's Basketball | HM | Forward |
| 1999 | Lisa Witherspoon | Women's Basketball | HM | Guard |
| 2000 | André Davis | Football | 1st | Punt Returner |
| 2000 | Sean Gray | Wrestling | 7th Place | 141 lbs. |
| 2000 | Brian Hunter | Track & Field | Indoor | Pole Vault |
| 2000 | Erick Kingston | Track & Field | Outdoor | Hammer Throw |
| 2000 | Matt Lehr | Football | 2nd | Offensive Guard |
| 2000 | Chris Martin | Wrestling | 4th Place | 165 lbs. |
| 2000 | Lee Suggs | Football | 3rd | Tailback |
| 2000 | Ben Taylor | Football | 3rd | Linebacker |
| 2000 | Dawn Will | Lacrosse | 3rd | MF |
| 2001 | Sean Gray | Wrestling | 6th Place | 141 lbs. |
| 2001 | Kristin Price | Track & Field | Indoor | 3,000 |
| 2001 | Kristin Price | Track & Field | Outdoor | 5,000 |
| 2001 | David Pugh | Football | 3rd | Defensive Tackle |
| 2001 | Ben Taylor | Football | 2nd | Linebacker |
| 2001 | Ronyell Whitaker | Football | 3rd | Cornerback |
| 2002 | Brendon de Jonge | Men's Golf | 2nd | |
| 2002 | Jake Grove | Football | 4th | Center |
| 2002 | Dee O'Connell | Track & Field | Outdoor | Javelin |
| 2002 | Willie Pile | Football | 2nd | Free Safety |
| 2002 | Johnson Wagner | Men's Golf | 3rd | |
| 2003 | Matt Dalton | Baseball | 1st | Pitcher |
| 2003 | Brendon de Jonge | Men's Golf | 2nd | |
| 2003 | Jake Grove U | Football | 1st | Center |
| 2003 | DeAngelo Hall | Football | 2nd | Cornerback |
| 2003 | Kevin Jones C | Football | 1st | Tailback |
| 2003 | Spyridon Jullien | Track & Field | Outdoor | Hammer Throw |
| 2003 | Marlies Overbeeke | Cross Country | ||
| 2003 | Marc Tugwell | Baseball | 2nd | Second Base |
| 2004 | Gus Calado | Swimming & Diving | HM | 200 Butterfly |
| 2004 | Spyridon Jullien | Track & Field | Indoor | Weight Throw |
| 2004 | Spyridon Jullien | Track & Field | Outdoor | Hammer Throw |
| 2004 | Bryant Matthews | Men's Basketball | HM | Guard/Forward |
| 2004 | Marlies Overbeeke | Track & Field | Outdoor | 1,500 |
| 2005 | Jessica Botzum | Swimming & Diving | 200 Breaststroke | |
| 2005 | Jessica Botzum | Swimming & Diving | HM | 100 Breaststroke |
| 2005 | Tamara Burns | Track & Field | Indoor | Weight Throw |
| 2005 | Kristen Callan | Track & Field | Outdoor | Hammer Throw |
| 2005 | Kevin Furlong | Swimming & Diving | HM | 100 Breaststroke |
| 2005 | Sven Hahn | Track & Field | Outdoor | Shot Put |
| 2005 | Spyridon Jullien | Track & Field | Indoor | Weight Throw |
| 2005 | Spyridon Jullien | Track & Field | Outdoor | Hammer Throw |
| 2005 | Brian Mondschein | Track & Field | Indoor | Pole Vault |
| 2005 | Brian Mondschein | Track & Field | Outdoor | Pole Vault |
| 2005 | Ryan Norwood | Track & Field | Indoor | Shot Put |
| 2005 | Darryl Tapp | Football | 1st | Defensive End |
| 2005 | Saskia Triesscheijn | Track & Field | Indoor | Pentathlon |
| 2005 | Jimmy Williams U | Football | 1st | Cornerback |
| 2006 | Tom Alberi | Swimming & Diving | HM | 800 Freestyle Relay |
| 2006 | Mohsen Anani | Track & Field | Indoor | Weight Throw |
| 2006 | Mohsen Anani | Track & Field | Outdoor | Hammer Throw |
| 2006 | Scott Beard | Swimming & Diving | HM | 800 Freestyle Relay |
| 2006 | Jessica Botzum | Swimming & Diving | HM | 200 Breaststroke |
| 2006 | Tamara Burns | Track & Field | Indoor | Weight Throw |
| 2006 | Gus Calado | Swimming & Diving | 200 Butterfly | |
| 2006 | Gus Calado | Swimming & Diving | HM | 800 Freestyle Relay |
| 2006 | Kristen Callan | Track & Field | Outdoor | Hammer Throw |
| 2006 | Zac Czaplicki | Swimming & Diving | HM | 800 Freestyle Relay |
| 2006 | Katie Esbrook | Volleyball | HM | Middle Blocker |
| 2006 | Mike Faust | Wrestling | 5th Place | 285 lbs. |
| 2006 | Brandon Flowers | Football | 3rd | Cornerback |
| 2006 | David Hoffman | Wrestling | 8th Place | 141 lbs. |
| 2006 | Spyridon Jullien | Track & Field | Indoor | Weight Throw |
| 2006 | Spyridon Jullien | Track & Field | Outdoor | Hammer Throw |
| 2006 | Brian Mondschein | Track & Field | Outdoor | Pole Vault |
| 2006 | Matej Muza | Track & Field | Outdoor | Hammer Throw |
| 2006 | Angela Tincher | Softball | 2nd | Pitcher |
| 2006 | Saskia Triesscheijn | Track & Field | Indoor | Pentathlon |
| 2006 | Saskia Triesscheijn | Track & Field | Outdoor | Heptathlon |
| 2007 | Xavier Adibi | Football | 1st | Linebacker |
| 2007 | Jessica Botzum | Swimming & Diving | 100 Breaststroke | |
| 2007 | Jessica Botzum | Swimming & Diving | 200 Breaststroke | |
| 2007 | Kristi Castlin | Track & Field | Indoor | 60m Hurdles |
| 2007 | Kristi Castlin | Track & Field | Outdoor | 100m Hurdles |
| 2007 | Justin Clickett | Track & Field | Indoor | Shot Put |
| 2007 | Justin Clickett | Track & Field | Outdoor | Shot Put |
| 2007 | Zabian Dowdell | Men's Basketball | HM | Guard |
| 2007 | Jessica Fanning | Track & Field | Indoor | DMR |
| 2007 | Tasmin Fanning | Track & Field | Indoor | DMR |
| 2007 | Tasmin Fanning | Cross Country | ||
| 2007 | Brandon Flowers | Football | 1st | Cornerback |
| 2007 | Sherlenia Green | Track & Field | Indoor | DMR |
| 2007 | Queen Harrison | Track & Field | Outdoor | 100m Hurdles |
| 2007 | Queen Harrison | Track & Field | Outdoor | 400m Hurdles |
| 2007 | Thorsten Mueller | Track & Field | Indoor | Pole Vault |
| 2007 | Patrick Nyarko | Men's Soccer | 1st | Forward |
| 2007 | Brittany Pryor | Track & Field | Indoor | Shot Put |
| 2007 | Brittany Pryor | Track & Field | Outdoor | Shot Put |
| 2007 | Sara Smith | Swimming & Diving | HM | 50 Freestyle |
| 2007 | Sara Smith | Swimming & Diving | 100 Freestyle | |
| 2007 | Britni Spruill | Track & Field | Outdoor | 200 |
| 2007 | Angela Tincher | Softball | 1st | Pitcher |
| 2007 | Asia Washington | Track & Field | Indoor | DMR |
| 2008 | Jessica Botzum | Swimming & Diving | 100 Breaststroke | |
| 2008 | Jessica Botzum | Swimming & Diving | 200 Breaststroke | |
| 2008 | Jessica Botzum | Swimming & Diving | HM | 200 Medley Relay |
| 2008 | Jessica Botzum | Swimming & Diving | HM | 400 Medley Relay |
| 2008 | Kristen Callan | Track & Field | Indoor | Weight Throw |
| 2008 | Kristen Callan | Track & Field | Outdoor | Hammer Throw |
| 2008 | Kristi Castlin | Track & Field | Indoor | 60m Hurdles |
| 2008 | Justin Clickett | Track & Field | Outdoor | Shot Put |
| 2008 | Tasmin Fanning | Track & Field | Outdoor | 5,000 |
| 2008 | Tasmin Fanning | Cross Country | ||
| 2008 | Sherlenia Green | Track & Field | Outdoor | 400m Hurdles |
| 2008 | Victor "Macho" Harris | Football | 1st | Cornerback |
| 2008 | Queen Harrison | Track & Field | Indoor | 60m Hurdles |
| 2008 | Mikey McDonald | Swimming & Diving | HM | 1 Meter Diving |
| 2008 | Mikey McDonald | Swimming & Diving | HM | Platform Diving |
| 2008 | Jordan McHorney | Swimming & Diving | HM | 200 Medley Relay |
| 2008 | Jordan McHorney | Swimming & Diving | HM | 400 Medley Relay |
| 2008 | Matej Muza | Track & Field | Outdoor | Hammer Throw |
| 2008 | Megan Newell | Swimming & Diving | HM | 200 Medley Relay |
| 2008 | Megan Newell | Swimming & Diving | HM | 400 Medley Relay |
| 2008 | Yavgeniy Olhovsky | Track & Field | Indoor | Pole Vault |
| 2008 | Yavgeniy Olhovsky | Track & Field | Outdoor | Pole Vault |
| 2008 | Kelly Phillips | Track & Field | Outdoor | Pole Vault |
| 2008 | Brittany Pryor | Track & Field | Indoor | Shot Put |
| 2008 | Brittany Pryor | Track & Field | Outdoor | Hammer Throw |
| 2008 | Brittany Pryor | Track & Field | Outdoor | Shot Put |
| 2008 | Sara Smith | Swimming & Diving | HM | 50 Freestyle |
| 2008 | Sara Smith | Swimming & Diving | HM | 200 Medley Relay |
| 2008 | Sara Smith | Swimming & Diving | HM | 400 Medley Relay |
| 2008 | Angela Tincher | Softball | 1st | Pitcher |
| 2008 | Jurrian van der Vaart | Men's Golf | 3rd | |
| 2008 | Felicia Willoughby | Volleyball | HM | Middle Blocker |
| 2009 | Kristi Castlin | Track & Field | Indoor | 60m Hurdles |
| 2009 | Kristi Castlin | Track & Field | Outdoor | 100m Hurdles |
| 2009 | Steffi Drechsel | Swimming & Diving | HM | 400 Freestyle Relay |
| 2009 | Cody Grimm | Football | 3rd | Linebacker |
| 2009 | Dorotea Habazin | Track & Field | Outdoor | Hammer Throw |
| 2009 | Erika Hajnal | Swimming & Diving | HM | 1650 Freestyle |
| 2009 | Hunter Hall | Track & Field | Indoor | Pole Vault |
| 2009 | Hunter Hall | Track & Field | Outdoor | Pole Vault |
| 2009 | Marcel Lomnicky | Track & Field | Indoor | Weight Throw |
| 2009 | Marcel Lomnicky | Track & Field | Outdoor | Hammer Throw |
| 2009 | Mikey McDonald | Swimming & Diving | HM | 1-Meter Diving |
| 2009 | Mikey McDonald | Swimming & Diving | HM | 3-Meter Diving |
| 2009 | Jordan McHorney | Swimming & Diving | HM | 400 Freestyle Relay |
| 2009 | Megan Newell | Swimming & Diving | HM | 400 Freestyle Relay |
| 2009 | Yavgeniy Olhovsky | Track & Field | Indoor | Pole Vault |
| 2009 | Yavgeniy Olhovsky | Track & Field | Outdoor | Pole Vault |
| 2009 | Brittany Pryor | Track & Field | Outdoor | Hammer Throw |
| 2009 | Jenna Rhodes | Softball | 3rd | At-Large Outfield |
| 2009 | Natalie Sherbak | Track & Field | Indoor | Mile |
| 2009 | Sara Smith | Swimming & Diving | HM | 50 Freestyle |
| 2009 | Sara Smith | Swimming & Diving | HM | 400 Freestyle Relay |
| 2009 | Asia Washington | Track & Field | Outdoor | 400m Hurdles |
| 2009 | Drew Weaver | Men's Golf | 3rd | |
| 2009 | Ryan Williams | Football | 3rd | Tailback |
| 2009 | Felicia Willoughby | Volleyball | HM | Middle Blocker |
| 2010 | Cara Baarendse | Volleyball | HM | Middle Blocker |
| 2010 | Kristi Castlin | Track & Field | Indoor | 60m Hurdles |
| 2010 | Kristi Castlin | Track & Field | Outdoor | 100m Hurdles |
| 2010 | Malcolm Delaney | Men's Basketball | HM | Guard |
| 2010 | Kelly deMarrais | Swimming & Diving | HM | 800 Freestyle Relay |
| 2010 | Chris Diaz | Wrestling | 8th Place | 141 lbs. |
| 2010 | Steve Domecus | Baseball | 3rd | Catcher |
| 2010 | Katarina Filova | Swimming & Diving | 200 Freestyle | |
| 2010 | Katarina Filova | Swimming & Diving | HM | 800 Freestyle Relay |
| 2010 | Dorotea Habazin | Track & Field | Outdoor | Hammer Throw |
| 2010 | Erika Hajnal | Swimming & Diving | 400 Individual Medley | |
| 2010 | Erika Hajnal | Swimming & Diving | HM | 800 Freestyle Relay |
| 2010 | Queen Harrison | Track & Field | Indoor | 60m Hurdles |
| 2010 | Queen Harrison | Track & Field | Outdoor | 400m Hurdles |
| 2010 | Queen Harrison | Track & Field | Outdoor | 100m Hurdles |
| 2010 | Jayron Hosley | Football | 1st | Cornerback |
| 2010 | Jared Jodon | Track & Field | Outdoor | Pole Vault |
| 2010 | Marcel Lomnicky | Track & Field | Outdoor | Hammer Throw |
| 2010 | Will Mulherin | Track & Field | Outdoor | 5,000 |
| 2010 | Yavgeniy Olhovsky | Track & Field | Indoor | Pole Vault |
| 2010 | Yavgeniy Olhovsky | Track & Field | Outdoor | Pole Vault |
| 2010 | Lauren Ritter | Swimming & Diving | HM | 800 Freestyle Relay |
| 2010 | Felicia Willoughby | Volleyball | HM | Middle Blocker |
| 2010 | Alexander Ziegler | Track & Field | Indoor | Weight Throw |
| 2010 | Alexander Ziegler | Track & Field | Outdoor | Hammer Throw |
| 2011 | Cara Baarendse | Volleyball | HM | Middle Blocker |
| 2011 | Ronnie Black | Track & Field | Outdoor | High Jump |
| 2011 | Samira Burkhardt | Track & Field | Indoor | Shot Put (2nd Team) |
| 2011 | Samira Burkhardt | Track & Field | Outdoor | Shot Put |
| 2011 | Joe Davis | Track & Field | Outdoor | Pole Vault |
| 2011 | Malcolm Delaney | Men's Basketball | HM | Guard |
| 2011 | Dorotea Habazin | Track & Field | Outdoor | Hammer Throw |
| 2011 | Hasheem Halim | Track & Field | Indoor | Triple Jump (2nd Team) |
| 2011 | Hasheem Halim | Track & Field | Outdoor | Triple Jump |
| 2011 | Hunter Hall | Track & Field | Indoor | Pole Vault |
| 2011 | Hunter Hall | Track & Field | Outdoor | Pole Vault (2nd Team) |
| 2011 | Michael Hammond | Track & Field | Indoor | Mile |
| 2011 | Michael Hammond | Track & Field | Outdoor | 1,500 (2nd Team) |
| 2011 | Marcel Lomnicky | Track & Field | Indoor | Weight Throw (2nd Team) |
| 2011 | Marcel Lomnicky | Track & Field | Outdoor | Hammer Throw |
| 2011 | Denis Mahmic | Track & Field | Outdoor | Hammer Throw (2nd Team) |
| 2011 | Will Mulherin | Cross Country | ||
| 2011 | Yavgeniy Olhovsky | Track & Field | Indoor | Pole Vault |
| 2011 | Kelly Phillips | Track & Field | Indoor | Pole Vault (2nd Team) |
| 2011 | Logan Shinholser | Swimming & Diving | Platform Diving | |
| 2011 | Matthias Treff | Track & Field | Outdoor | Javelin |
| 2011 | David Wilson | Track & Field | Outdoor | Triple Jump |
| 2011 | David Wilson | Football | 2nd | Tailback |
| 2011 | Alexander Ziegler | Track & Field | Indoor | Weight Throw |
| 2011 | Alexander Ziegler | Track & Field | Outdoor | Hammer Throw |
| 2012 | Kaylea Arnett | Swimming & Diving | HM | 1-Meter Diving |
| 2012 | Kaylea Arnett | Swimming & Diving | Platform Diving | |
| 2012 | Jeff Artis-Gray | Track & Field | Outdoor | Long Jump |
| 2012 | Jeff Artis-Gray | Track & Field | Outdoor | 4x100-meter relay (2nd team) |
| 2012 | Ronnie Black | Track & Field | Indoor | High Jump (2nd Team) |
| 2012 | Ronnie Black | Track & Field | Outdoor | High Jump |
| 2012 | Devin Carter | Wrestling | 5th Place | 133 lbs. |
| 2012 | Joe Davis | Track & Field | Outdoor | Pole Vault |
| 2012 | Frances Dowd | Track & Field | Indoor | 800 (2nd Team) |
| 2012 | Erika Hajnal | Swimming & Diving | HM | 500 Freestyle |
| 2012 | Hasheem Halim | Track & Field | Indoor | Triple Jump |
| 2012 | Hasheem Halim | Track & Field | Outdoor | Triple Jump |
| 2012 | Hunter Hall | Track & Field | Outdoor | Pole Vault (2nd team) |
| 2012 | Michael Hammond | Track & Field | Outdoor | 1500 |
| 2012 | Ryan Hawkins | Swimming & Diving | Platform Diving | |
| 2012 | Logan Kline | Swimming & Diving | 1-Meter Diving | |
| 2012 | Logan Kline | Swimming & Diving | HM | 3-Meter Diving |
| 2012 | Marcel Lomnicky | Track & Field | Indoor | Weight Throw |
| 2012 | Gregory Mahon | Swimming & Diving | HM | 200 Butterfly |
| 2012 | Jonathan McCants | Track & Field | Outdoor | 4x100-meter relay (2nd team) |
| 2012 | Zach McGinnis | Swimming & Diving | HM | 200 Backstroke |
| 2012 | Will Mulherin | Cross Country | ||
| 2012 | Valentina Muzaric | Track & Field | Outdoor | Shot Put (2nd team) |
| 2012 | Keith Ricks | Track & Field | Indoor | 60 (2nd Team) |
| 2012 | Keith Ricks | Track & Field | Outdoor | 4x100-meter relay (2nd team) |
| 2012 | Heather Savage | Swimming & Diving | 100 Butterfly | |
| 2012 | Martina Schultze | Track & Field | Indoor | Pole Vault |
| 2012 | Martina Schultze | Track & Field | Outdoor | Pole Vault (2nd team) |
| 2012 | Logan Shinholser | Swimming & Diving | 1-Meter Diving | |
| 2012 | Logan Shinholser | Swimming & Diving | 3-Meter Diving | |
| 2012 | Logan Shinholser | Swimming & Diving | Platform Diving | |
| 2012 | Kelli Stockton | Swimming & Diving | HM | Platform Diving |
| 2012 | Matthias Treff | Track & Field | Outdoor | Javelin |
| 2012 | Victoria von Eynatten | Track & Field | Indoor | Pole Vault |
| 2012 | Darrell Wesh | Track & Field | Outdoor | 100 |
| 2012 | Darrell Wesh | Track & Field | Outdoor | 4x100 meter relay (2nd team) |
| 2012 | Pete Yates | Wrestling | 5th Place | 165 lbs. |
| 2012 | Alexander Ziegler | Track & Field | Indoor | Weight Throw |
| 2012 | Alexander Ziegler | Track & Field | Outdoor | Hammer Throw |
| 2013 | Kaylea Arnett | Swimming & Diving | HM | 1-Meter Diving |
| 2013 | Kaylea Arnett | Swimming & Diving | HM | Platform Diving |
| 2013 | Jeff Artis-Gray | Track & Field | Indoor | Long Jump |
| 2013 | Jeff Artis-Gray | Track & Field | Indoor | DMR (2nd Team) |
| 2013 | Jeff Artis-Gray | Track & Field | Outdoor | Long Jump |
| 2013 | Ronnie Black | Track & Field | Indoor | High Jump |
| 2013 | Ronnie Black | Track & Field | Outdoor | High Jump (2nd Team) |
| 2013 | Joe Bonk | Swimming & Diving | HM | 200 Freestyle Relay |
| 2013 | Joe Bonk | Swimming & Diving | HM | 200 Medley Relay |
| 2013 | Joe Bonk | Swimming & Diving | HM | 400 Medley Relay |
| 2013 | Nick Brascetta | Wrestling | 8th Place | 149 lbs. |
| 2013 | Kathryn Caine | Volleyball | HM | Middle Blocker/Right-Side |
| 2013 | Tihut Degfae | Track & Field | Indoor | DMR (2nd Team) |
| 2013 | Emmett Dignan | Swimming & Diving | HM | 200 Freestyle Relay |
| 2013 | Emmett Dignan | Swimming & Diving | HM | 400 Medley Relay |
| 2013 | Kyle Fuller | Football | 2nd | Cornerback |
| 2013 | Jarrod Garnett | Wrestling | 6th Place | 125 lbs. |
| 2013 | Erick Green | Men's Basketball | 3rd | Guard |
| 2013 | Ryan Hagen | Track & Field | Indoor | DMR (2nd Team) |
| 2013 | Michael Hammond | Track & Field | Indoor | DMR (2nd Team) |
| 2013 | Victoria Hamsher | Volleyball | HM | Middle Blocker |
| 2013 | Ryan Hawkins | Swimming & Diving | 3 Meter Diving | |
| 2013 | Ryan Hawkins | Swimming & Diving | HM | 1-Meter Diving |
| 2013 | Ryan Hawkins | Swimming & Diving | Platform Diving | |
| 2013 | Nathan Hoisington | Swimming & Diving | HM | 200 Medley Relay |
| 2013 | Tyler Horan | Baseball | 2nd | Outfield |
| 2013 | Logan Kline | Swimming & Diving | HM | 3-Meter Diving |
| 2013 | Tomas Kruzliak | Track & Field | Indoor | Weight Throw (2nd Team) |
| 2013 | Tomas Kruzliak | Track & Field | Outdoor | Hammer Throw |
| 2013 | Gregory Mahon | Swimming & Diving | HM | 100 Butterfly |
| 2013 | Gregory Mahon | Swimming & Diving | HM | 200 Freestyle Relay |
| 2013 | Gregory Mahon | Swimming & Diving | HM | 200 Medley Relay |
| 2013 | Gregory Mahon | Swimming & Diving | HM | 400 Medley Relay |
| 2013 | Zach McGinnis | Swimming & Diving | HM | 100 Backstroke |
| 2013 | Zach McGinnis | Swimming & Diving | HM | 200 Freestyle Relay |
| 2013 | Zach McGinnis | Swimming & Diving | HM | 200 Medley Relay |
| 2013 | Zach McGinnis | Swimming & Diving | HM | 400 Medley Relay |
| 2013 | Will Mulherin | Track & Field | Indoor | 3,000 |
| 2013 | Zach Neibert | Wrestling | 8th Place | 141 lbs. |
| 2013 | Jazmine Reeves | Women's Soccer | 1st | Forward |
| 2013 | Heather Savage | Swimming & Diving | 100 Butterfly | |
| 2013 | Martina Schultze | Track & Field | Indoor | Pole Vault |
| 2013 | Martina Schultze | Track & Field | Outdoor | Pole Vault |
| 2013 | Logan Shinholser | Swimming & Diving | HM | Platform Diving |
| 2013 | Matthias Treff | Track & Field | Outdoor | Javelin (2nd Team) |
| 2013 | Chris Uhle | Track & Field | Outdoor | Pole Vault (2nd Team) |
| 2013 | Annjulie Vester | Track & Field | Outdoor | Hammer Throw (2nd Team) |
| 2013 | Darrell Wesh | Track & Field | Indoor | 60 |
| 2013 | Pete Yates | Wrestling | 4th Place | 165 lbs. |
| 2013 | Alexander Ziegler | Track & Field | Indoor | Weight Throw |
| 2014 | Kaylea Arnett | Swimming & Diving | 1-Meter Diving | |
| 2014 | Kaylea Arnett | Swimming & Diving | HM | 3-Meter Diving |
| 2014 | Kaylea Arnett | Swimming & Diving | HM | Platform Diving |
| 2014 | Devin Carter | Wrestling | 2nd Place | 141 |
| 2014 | Martin Dally | Track & Field | Indoor | DMR |
| 2014 | Joey Dance | Wrestling | 4th Place | 125 |
| 2014 | Leoule Degfae | Track & Field | Indoor | DMR |
| 2014 | Tihut Degfae | Track & Field | Indoor | DMR |
| 2014 | Kendall Fuller | Football | 2nd | Cornerback |
| 2014 | Ryan Hawkins | Swimming & Diving | HM | 1-Meter Diving |
| 2014 | Ryan Hawkins | Swimming & Diving | HM | 3-Meter Diving |
| 2014 | Ryan Hawkins | Swimming & Diving | Platform Diving | |
| 2014 | Collin Higgins | Swimming & Diving | HM | 200 Backstroke |
| 2014 | Torben Laidig | Track & Field | Indoor | Pole Vault |
| 2014 | Weronika Paluszek | Swimming & Diving | HM | 100 Breaststroke |
| 2014 | Weronika Paluszek | Swimming & Diving | HM | 200 Breaststroke |
| 2014 | Chris Penny | Wrestling | Sixth Place | 197 |
| 2014 | Grant Pollock | Track & Field | Indoor | DMR |
| 2014 | Martina Schultze | Track & Field | Indoor | Pole Vault |
| 2014 | T.J. Shinholser | Swimming & Diving | Platform Diving | |
| 2014 | Amanda Smith | Track & Field | Indoor | 800 |
| 2014 | Scott Vincent | Men's Golf | 1st | |
| 2015 | Kaylea Arnett | Swimming & Diving | 3-Meter Diving | |
| 2015 | Kaylea Arnett | Swimming & Diving | HM | Platform Diving |
| 2015 | Nick Brascetta | Wrestling | 4th Place | 157 |
| 2015 | Owen Burns | Swimming & Diving | HM | 400 Medley Relay |
| 2015 | Juan Campos | Track & Field | Indoor | DMR (2nd Team) |
| 2015 | Devin Carter | Wrestling | 3rd Place | 141 |
| 2015 | Thomas Curtin | Track & Field | Indoor | 3,000 |
| 2015 | Thomas Curtin | Track & Field | Indoor | 5,000 |
| 2015 | Thomas Curtin | Track & Field | Outdoor | 5,000 |
| 2015 | Thomas Curtin | Cross Country | ||
| 2015 | Zach Epperly | Wrestling | 7th Place | 174 |
| 2015 | Brandon Fiala | Swimming & Diving | HM | 400 Medley Relay |
| 2015 | Neil Gourley | Track & Field | Indoor | DMR (2nd Team) |
| 2015 | Hanna Green | Track & Field | Indoor | 800 |
| 2015 | Hanna Green | Track & Field | Outdoor | 800 |
| 2015 | Collin Higgins | Swimming & Diving | HM | 400 Medley Relay |
| 2015 | Patrick Joseph | Track & Field | Indoor | Mile (2nd Team) |
| 2015 | Tomas Kruzliak | Track & Field | Indoor | Weight Throw (2nd Team) |
| 2015 | Tomas Kruzliak | Track & Field | Outdoor | Hammer Throw |
| 2015 | Morgan Latimer | Swimming & Diving | HM | 400 Medley Relay |
| 2015 | Klaudia Nazieblo | Swimming & Diving | HM | 200 Butterfly |
| 2015 | Prince Owusu | Track & Field | Indoor | DMR (2nd Team) |
| 2015 | Weronika Paluszek | Swimming & Diving | 200 Breaststroke | |
| 2015 | Grant Pollock | Track & Field | Indoor | DMR (2nd Team) |
| 2015 | Irena Sediva | Track & Field | Outdoor | Javelin |
| 2015 | Amanda Smith | Track & Field | Indoor | 800 (2nd Team) |
| 2015 | Murielle Tiernan | Women's Soccer | Third | Forward |
| 2015 | Ty Walz | Wrestling | 7th Place | Heavyweight |
| 2015 | Manuel Ziegler | Track & Field | Indoor | Triple Jump |
| 2016 | Marcelo Acuna | Men's Soccer | Third | Forward |
| 2016 | Marek Barta | Track & Field | Outdoor | Discus |
| 2016 | Nick Brascetta | Wrestling | 3rd Place | 157 lbs. |
| 2016 | Solomon Chishko | Wrestling | 6th Place | 141 lbs. |
| 2016 | Thomas Curtin | Track & Field | Indoor | 5,000 |
| 2016 | Thomas Curtin | Track & Field | Outdoor | 5,000 |
| 2016 | Zach Epperly | Wrestling | 3rd Place | 174 lbs. |
| 2016 | Brandon Fiala | Swimming & Diving | 200 Individual Medley | |
| 2016 | Brandon Fiala | Swimming & Diving | 100 Breaststroke | |
| 2016 | Brandon Fiala | Swimming & Diving | 200 Breaststroke | |
| 2016 | Neil Gourley | Track & Field | Outdoor | 1,500 (2nd Team) |
| 2016 | Hanna Green | Track & Field | Indoor | 800 |
| 2016 | Maggie Gruber | Swimming & Diving | HM | 400 Medley Relay |
| 2016 | Jared Haught | Wrestling | 6th Place | 197 lbs. |
| 2016 | Jessica Hespeler | Swimming & Diving | HM | 400 Medley Relay |
| 2016 | Brad Johnson | Track & Field | Outdoor | Pole Vault (2nd Team) |
| 2016 | Patrick Joseph | Track & Field | Outdoor | 800 (2nd Team) |
| 2016 | Sabine Kopplin | Track & Field | Outdoor | Javelin (2nd Team) |
| 2016 | Thomas Kruzliak | Track & Field | Outdoor | Hammer Throw (2nd Team) |
| 2016 | Torben Laidig | Track & Field | Outdoor | Pole Vault |
| 2016 | David McFadden | Wrestling | 6th Place | 165 lbs. |
| 2016 | Joao Monteiro | Men's Tennis | ||
| 2016 | Shannon Morton | Track & Field | Indoor | Mile (2nd Team) |
| 2016 | Klaudia Nazieblo | Swimming & Diving | 200 Butterfly | |
| 2016 | Klaudia Nazieblo | Swimming & Diving | HM | 400 Medley Relay |
| 2016 | Robert Owen | Swimming & Diving | HM | 400 Individual Medley |
| 2016 | Robert Owen | Swimming & Diving | HM | 200 Backstroke |
| 2016 | Weronika Paluszek | Swimming & Diving | HM | 200 Breaststroke |
| 2016 | Weronika Paluszek | Swimming & Diving | HM | 400 Medley Relay |
| 2016 | Deakin Volz | Track & Field | Indoor | Pole Vault |
| 2016 | Ty Walz | Wrestling | 4th Place | Heavyweight |
| 2017 | Marek Barta | Track & Field | Outdoor | Discus |
| 2017 | Greg Chiles | Track & Field | Indoor | DMR |
| 2017 | Solomon Chishko | Wrestling | Sixth | 149 lbs. |
| 2017 | Kevin Cianfarini | Track & Field | Indoor | DMR |
| 2017 | Vincent Ciattei | Track & Field | Indoor | DMR |
| 2017 | Vincent Ciattei | Track & Field | Outdoor | 1,500 (2nd Team) |
| 2017 | Joey Dance | Wrestling | 5th Place | 125 lbs. |
| 2017 | Fiona Donnelly | Swimming & Diving | HM | 800 Free Relay |
| 2017 | Sarah Edwards | Track & Field | Outdoor | 3,000 Steeple (2nd Team) |
| 2017 | Brandon Fiala | Swimming & Diving | 100 Breaststroke | |
| 2017 | Brandon Fiala | Swimming & Diving | 200 Breaststroke | |
| 2017 | Brandon Fiala | Swimming & Diving | HM | 200 Individual Medley |
| 2017 | Neil Gourley | Track & Field | Indoor | Mile |
| 2017 | Neil Gourley | Track & Field | Outdoor | 1,500 |
| 2017 | Hanna Green | Track & Field | Indoor | 800 |
| 2017 | Hanna Green | Track & Field | Outdoor | 800 |
| 2017 | Reka Gyorgy | Swimming & Diving | 400 Individual Medley | |
| 2017 | Reka Gyorgy | Swimming & Diving | HM | 800 Free Relay |
| 2017 | Jared Haught | Wrestling | 4th Place | 197 lbs. |
| 2017 | Jessica Hespeler | Swimming & Diving | HM | 800 Free Relay |
| 2017 | Jessica Hespeler | Swimming & Diving | HM | 200 Butterfly |
| 2017 | Daniel Jaskowak | Track & Field | Indoor | DMR |
| 2017 | Brad Johnson | Track & Field | Outdoor | Pole Vault (2nd Team) |
| 2017 | Patrick Joseph | Track & Field | Indoor | 800 (2nd Team) |
| 2017 | Patrick Joseph | Track & Field | Outdoor | 800 (2nd Team) |
| 2017 | Pavla Kuklova | Track & Field | Outdoor | Hammer Throw (2nd Team) |
| 2017 | Torben Laidig | Track & Field | Indoor | Pole Vault |
| 2017 | Sal Mastriani | Wrestling | 8th Place | 157 lbs. |
| 2017 | Klaudia Nazieblo | Swimming & Diving | HM | 800 Free Relay |
| 2017 | Klaudia Nazieblo | Swimming & Diving | HM | 200 Butterfly |
| 2017 | Robert Owen | Swimming & Diving | 400 Individual Medley | |
| 2017 | Ashlynn Peters | Swimming & Diving | 3-Meter | |
| 2017 | Drew Piazza | Track & Field | Indoor | 800 |
| 2017 | Drew Piazza | Track & Field | Outdoor | 800 |
| 2017 | Irena Sediva | Track & Field | Outdoor | Javelin |
| 2017 | Peter Seufer | Track & Field | Outdoor | 5,000 (2nd Team) |
| 2017 | Emma Thor | Track & Field | Outdoor | Hammer Throw |
| 2017 | Deakin Volz | Track & Field | Indoor | Pole Vault (2nd Team) |
| 2017 | Ty Walz | Wrestling | 4th Place | Heavyweight |
| 2018 | Laurie Barton | Track & Field | Indoor | DMR |
| 2018 | Rachel Baxter | Track & Field | Indoor | Pole Vault (2nd Team) |
| 2018 | Courtney Blanden | Track & Field | Indoor | DMR |
| 2018 | Greg Chiles | Track & Field | Indoor | DMR |
| 2018 | Vincent Ciattei | Track & Field | Indoor | DMR |
| 2018 | Vincent Ciattei | Track & Field | Indoor | Mile |
| 2018 | Sarah Edwards | Track & Field | Indoor | DMR |
| 2018 | Neil Gourley | Track & Field | Indoor | DMR |
| 2018 | Neil Gourley | Track & Field | Indoor | Mile |
| 2018 | Lisa Gunnarsson | Track & Field | Indoor | Pole Vault |
| 2018 | Jared Haught | Wrestling | Second Place | 197 lbs. |
| 2018 | Patrick Joseph | Track & Field | Indoor | DMR |
| 2018 | Patrick Joseph | Track & Field | Indoor | Mile |
| 2018 | Katie Kennedy | Track & Field | Indoor | DMR |
| 2018 | Torben Laidig | Track & Field | Indoor | Pole Vault (2nd Team) |
| 2018 | David McFadden | Wrestling | Fifth Place | 165 lbs. |
| 2018 | Paige Petty | Lacrosse | Third | Midfielder |
| 2018 | Rachel Pocratsky | Track & Field | Indoor | 800 |
| 2018 | Deakin Volz | Track & Field | Indoor | Pole Vault |
| 2018 | Eszter Bajnok | Track & Field | Outdoor | Triple Jump |
| 2018 | Rachel Baxter | Track & Field | Outdoor | Pole Vault |
| 2018 | Greg Chiles | Track & Field | Outdoor | 400 hurdles |
| 2018 | Vincent Ciattei | Track & Field | Outdoor | 1,500 |
| 2018 | Adriana Grabski | Swimming & Diving | HM | 200 Medley Relay |
| 2018 | Adriana Grabski | Swimming & Diving | HM | 400 Medley Relay |
| 2018 | Maggie Gruber | Swimming & Diving | HM | 200 Medley Relay |
| 2018 | Maggie Gruber | Swimming & Diving | HM | 400 Medley Relay |
| 2018 | Reka Gyorgy | Swimming & Diving | HM | 400 Individual Medley |
| 2018 | Lisa Gunnarsson | Track & Field | Outdoor | Pole Vault |
| 2018 | Pavla Kuklova | Track & Field | Outdoor | Hammer Throw |
| 2018 | Torben Laidig | Track & Field | Outdoor | Pole Vault |
| 2018 | Joel Leon Benitez | Track & Field | Outdoor | Pole Vault |
| 2018 | Klaudia Nazieblo | Swimming & Diving | HM | 200 Medley Relay |
| 2018 | Klaudia Nazieblo | Swimming & Diving | HM | 400 Medley Relay |
| 2018 | Klaudia Nazieblo | Swimming & Diving | HM | 200 Butterfly |
| 2018 | Rachel Pocratsky | Track & Field | Outdoor | 1,500 |
| 2018 | Emma Thor | Track & Field | Outdoor | Hammer Throw (2nd Team) |
| 2018 | Deakin Volz | Track & Field | Outdoor | Pole Vault |
| 2018 | Diego Zarate | Track & Field | Outdoor | 1,500 |
| 2018 | Ben Schiesl | Swimming & Diving | HM | 1-Meter |
| 2018 | Peter Seufer | Cross Country | ||
| 2018 | Joelle Vereb | Swimming & Diving | HM | 200 Medley Relay |
| 2018 | Joelle Vereb | Swimming & Diving | HM | 400 Medley Relay |
| 2018 | Zack Zavatsky | Wrestling | Sixth Place | 184 lbs. |
| 2019 | Rachel Baxter | Track & Field | Indoor | Pole Vault |
| 2019 | Arlicia Bush | Track & Field | Indoor | DMR (2nd Team) |
| 2019 | Sarah Edwards | Track & Field | Indoor | Mile |
| 2019 | Sara Freix | Track & Field | Indoor | DMR (2nd Team) |
| 2019 | Reka Gyorgy | Swimming & Diving | HM | 400 Individual Medley |
| 2019 | Antani Ivanov | Swimming & Diving | HM | 200 Butterfly |
| 2019 | Mekhi Lewis | Wrestling | First Place | 165 lbs. |
| 2019 | David McFadden | Wrestling | Fifth Place | 174 lbs. |
| 2019 | Bashir Mosavel-Lo | Track & Field | Indoor | 800 (2nd Team) |
| 2019 | Rachel Pocratsky | Track & Field | Indoor | 800 |
| 2019 | Shannon Quinn | Track & Field | Indoor | DMR (2nd Team) |
| 2019 | Catherine Stone | Track & Field | Indoor | DMR (2nd Team) |
| 2019 | Lane Stone | Swimming & Diving | HM | 500 Freestyle |
| 2019 | Deakin Volz | Track & Field | Indoor | Pole Vault (2nd Team) |
| 2019 | Zack Zavatsky | Wrestling | Eighth Place | 184 lbs. |
| 2020 | Ian Seymour | Basball | Third | SP |
| 2020 | Carson Taylor | Baseball | Third | C |
| 2020 | Peter Seufer | Cross Country | ||
| 2020 | Paige Petty | Lacrosse | Third | MF |
| 2020 | Kayla Frank | Lacrosse | HM | MF |
| 2020 | Mandy McGlynn | Women's Soccer | Second | GK |
| 2020 | Keely Rochard | Softball | First | SP |
| 2020 | Filippo Dal Maso | Swimming & Diving | 800 Freestyle Relay | |
| 2020 | Thomas Hallock | Swimming & Diving | 50 Freestyle | |
| 2020 | Antani Ivanov | Swimming & Diving | 200 Butterfly | |
| 2020 | Antani Ivanov | Swimming & Diving | 800 Freestyle Relay | |
| 2020 | Blake Manoff | Swimming & Diving | 100 Butterfly | |
| 2020 | Blake Manoff | Swimming & Diving | 200 Butterfly | |
| 2020 | Blake Manoff | Swimming & Diving | 800 Freestyle Relay | |
| 2020 | Teagan Moravek | Swimming & Diving | 1-meter | |
| 2020 | Teagan Moravek | Swimming & Diving | 3-meter | |
| 2020 | AJ Pouch | Swimming & Diving | 200 Breaststroke | |
| 2020 | Lane Stone | Swimming & Diving | 800 Freestyle Relay | |
| 2020 | Sam Tornqvist | Swimming & Diving | 200 Backstroke | |
| 2020 | Joelle Vereb | Swimming & Diving | 50 Freestyle | |
| 2020 | Joelle Vereb | Swimming & Diving | 100 Butterfly | |
| 2020 | Regan Westwood | Swimming & Diving | 1-meter | |
| 2020 | Noah Zawadzki | Swimming & Diving | 1-meter | |
| 2020 | Noah Zawadzki | Swimming & Diving | 3-meter | |
| 2020 | Noah Zawadzki | Swimming & Diving | Platform | |
| 2020 | Rachel Baxter | Track & Field | Pole Vault | |
| 2020 | Arlicia Bush | Track & Field | DMR | |
| 2020 | Lindsey Butler | Track & Field | DMR | |
| 2020 | Sarah Edwards | Track & Field | Mile | |
| 2020 | Sarah Edwards | Track & Field | DMR | |
| 2020 | Patrick Forrest | Track & Field | DMR | |
| 2020 | Sara Freix | Track & Field | 3,000 | |
| 2020 | Sara Freix | Track & Field | DMR | |
| 2020 | Jack Joyce | Track & Field | DMR | |
| 2020 | Bashir Mosavel-Lo | Track & Field | DMR | |
| 2020 | Jacory Patterson | Track & Field | 400 | |
| 2020 | Peter Seufer | Track & Field | 5,000 | |
| 2020 | Peter Seufer | Track & Field | 3,000 | |
| 2020 | Peter Seufer | Track & Field | DMR | |
| 2020 | Caitlan Tate | Track & Field | 400 | |
| 2020 | Diego Zarate | Track & Field | Mile | |
| 2020 | David McFadden | Wrestling | 165 lbs. | |
| 2020 | Hunter Bolen | Wrestling | 184 lbs. | |
| 2020 | Daniel Pereira | Men's Soccer | Second (College Soccer News) | Midfielder |
| 2021 | Aisha Sheppard | Women's Basketball | HM | Guard |
| 2021 | Paige Petty | Lacrosse | HM (USA Lacrosse, Inside Lacrosse) | Attacker |
| 2021 | Keely Rochard | Softball | First (NFCA) | Pitcher |
| 2022 | Elizabeth Kitley | Women's Basketball | Second (The Athletic), Third (AP, USBWA) | Center |
| 2022 | Emily Mahar | Women's Golf | HM (WGCA) | |
| 2022 | Sarah Lubnow | Lacrosse | HM (USA Lacrosse) | Attacker |
| 2022 | Olivia Vergano | Lacrosse | HM (Inside Lacrosse) | Midfielder |
| 2022 | Emma Ritter | Softball | Third (NFCA) | Outfielder |
| 2022 | Keely Rochard | Softball | First (NFCA) | Pitcher |
| 2023 | Olivia Vergano | Lacrosse | HM (USA Lacrosse) | Attacker |
| 2023 | Elizabeth Kitley | Women's Baketball | Second (AP, The Athletic) | Center |
| 2023 | Georgia Amoore | Women's Basketball | HM (AP) | Guard |
| 2024 | Elizabeth Kitley | Women's Basketball | First (The Athletic, The Sporting News), Second (AP, USBWA) | Center |
| 2024 | Georgia Amoore | Women's Basketball | Third (AP, USBWA) | Guard |
| 2024 | Ben Watson | Baseball | Third | Outfielder |
| 2024 | Michelle Chatfield | Softball | Freshman (Softball America), All-Freshman (D1 Softball) | Infielder |
| 2024 | Addy Greene | Softball | First (NFCA) | Outfielder |
| 2024 | Cori McMillan | Softball | Second (NFCA), Second (Softball America) | Outfielder |
| 2024 | Emma Ritter | Softball | First (NFCA), First (D1 Softball) | Outfielder |
U - Unanimous Selection
C - Consensus Selection
Y - Academic All-American of the Year
Swimming & Diving and Wrestling: The top eight places in each event at the NCAA Championship are awarded All-American. (NOTE: In 2020, All-Americans in these two sports were chosen by each sport's respective coaches' association because the COVID-19 pandemic canceled the NCAA Championships.)
Tennis: In Singles: The top 16 seeds in the NCAA Championship, the final 16 in the NCAA Championship and the top 20 in the final ITA poll are awarded All-American. In Doubles: The top 8 seeds in the NCAA Championship, the final 8 in the NCAA Championship and the top 10 in the final ITA poll are awarded All-American.
Track & Field: Prior to 2011, the top eight places in each event at the NCAA Championships are awarded All-American. If a top eight finisher is not a US citizen, then the next US citizen place holder will be awarded All-American. Since 2011, the top eight places in each event at the NCAA Championship are awarded first-team All-American, places 9-16 are awarded second-team All-American and the team must have USTFCCCA membership. (NOTE: In 2020, All-Americans in track and field were chosen by the USTFCCCA because the COVID-19 pandemic canceled the NCAA Indoor Championships.)
Academic All-Americans
As selected by CoSIDA
| Year | Name | Sport | Team | Pos. |
|---|---|---|---|---|
| 1965 | Billy Edwards | Football | HM | DEF |
| 1966 | Sands Woody | Football | 2nd | G |
| 1967 | Frank Loria | Football | DB | |
| 1968 | Ted Ware | Men's Basketball | 1st | C/F |
| 1969 | Stan Kerrick | Men's Basketball | 2nd | |
| 1970 | Wayne Javins | Baseball | 1st | IF |
| 1971 | Tommy Carpenito | Football | 2nd | LB |
| 1972 | Tommy Carpenito | Football | 1st | LB |
| 1972 | Steve Magulgan | Football | 2nd | OG |
| 1975 | Tony Varbonceour | Baseball | 1st | 1B |
| 1982 | Mike Johnson | Football | 2nd | LB |
| 1982 | Ginny Lessman | Volleyball | 3rd | S |
| 1983 | Ginny Lessman | Volleyball | 1st | S |
| 1987 | Julie Neely | Volleyball | 3rd | B |
| 1990 | Nick Cullen | Football | 2nd | WR |
| 1991 | Lisa Pikalek | Volleyball | 2nd | OH |
| 1991 | Steve Render | Baseball | 1st | OF |
| 1992 | Lisa Pikalek Y | Volleyball | 1st | OH |
| 1992 | Steve Render | Baseball | 3rd | OF |
| 1994 | Christi Osborne | Women's Basketball | 2nd | F/C |
| 1995 | Christi Osborne | Women's Basketball | 1st | F/C |
| 1997 | Katie Ollendick | Track & Field | 1st | Women's At-Large |
| 1997 | Marek Pfeil | Men's Tennis | 3rd | At-Large |
| 1998 | Michelle Johnson | Softball | 3rd | P |
| 1998 | Michelle Meadows | Softball | 2nd | 2B |
| 1998 | Kristina Neptun | Swimming & Diving | 3rd | Women's At-Large |
| 1998 | Katie Ollendick Y | Track & Field | 1st | Women's At-Large |
| 1999 | Michelle Meadows | Softball | 1st | 2B |
| 2000 | Michelle Meadows | Softball | 1st | 2B |
| 2001 | André Davis | Football | 1st | WR |
| 2001 | Gregg Doulé | Swimming & Diving | 3rd | Men's At-Large |
| 2002 | Ashlee Dobbe | Softball | 1st | P |
| 2003 | Spencer Harris | Baseball | 2nd | SS |
| 2003 | Lasse Mertins | Men's Soccer | 3rd | D |
| 2004 | Tom Blaszak | Baseball | 1st | 2B |
| 2004 | Marlies Overbeeke | Cross Country/Track & Field | 2nd | |
| 2005 | Dustin Dyer | Men's Soccer | 3rd | D |
| 2005 | Brian MacPhee | Track & Field | 2nd | |
| 2006 | Mike Faust | Wrestling | 3rd | Men's At-Large |
| 2006 | Gunild Kreb | Track & Field | 2nd | |
| 2006 | Angela Tincher | Softball | 2nd | P |
| 2007 | Jessica Botzum | Swimming & Diving | 3rd | Women's At-Large |
| 2007 | Gunild Kreb | Track & Field | 1st | |
| 2007 | Lindsay Piper | Lacrosse | 3rd | Women's At-Large |
| 2007 | Joe Samaniuk | Track & Field | 3rd | |
| 2007 | Angela Tincher | Softball | 1st | P |
| 2008 | Jessica Botzum | Swimming & Diving | 2nd | Women's At-Large |
| 2008 | Brittany Cook | Women's Basketball | 3rd | |
| 2008 | Sherlenia Green | Track & Field | 1st | Women's At-Large |
| 2008 | Angela Tincher Y | Softball | 1st | P |
| 2009 | Laura Haskins | Women's Basketball | 3rd | |
| 2009 | Jenna Rhodes | Softball | 2nd | OF |
| 2010 | Martha Blakely | Women's Tennis | 3rd | Women's At-Large |
| 2010 | Matej Muza | Cross Country/Track & Field | 2nd | |
| 2010 | Kelly Phillips | Cross Country/Track & Field | 3rd | |
| 2011 | Danny Coale | Football | 2nd | WR |
| 2011 | Chris Drager | Football | 2nd | TE |
| 2011 | Kelly Phillips | Track & Field | 1st | |
| 2012 | Francis Dowd | Cross Country/Track & Field | 1st | |
| 2012 | Ryan Hawkins | Swimming & Diving | 3rd | Men's At-Large |
| 2012 | Logan Kline | Swimming & Diving | 2nd | Women's At-Large |
| 2012 | Alexander Ziegler | Cross Country/Track & Field | 2nd | |
| 2013 | Ryan Hawkins | Swimming & Diving | 3rd | Men's At-Large |
| 2013 | Alexander Ziegler | Cross Country/Track & Field | 1st | |
| 2014 | Devin Carter | Wrestling | 2nd | Men's At-Large |
| 2014 | Katie Yensen | Women's Soccer | 3rd | MF |
| 2015 | Devin Carter | Wrestling | 1st | Men's At-Large |
| 2015 | Erik Payne | Baseball | 2nd | IF |
| 2018 | Torben Laidig | Track & Field | 1st | |
| 2018 | Vincent Ciattei | Track & Field | 2nd | |
| 2023 | Ryan Fishback | Men's Tennis | 1st | At-Large |
| 2024 | Elizabeth Kitley | Women's Basketball | 1st | |
| 2024 | Georgia Amoore | Women's Basketball | 1st |
U - Unanimous Selection
C - Consensus Selection
Y - Academic All-American of the Year
Golf Coaches Association of America All-American Scholar
| Year | Name |
|---|---|
| 1985 | Jake Allison |
| 1986 | Mark Teachey |
| 2007 | Carl Wakely |
| 2008 | Jurrian van der Vaart |
| 2008 | Drew Weaver |
| 2009 | Drew Weaver |
| 2013 | Bryce Chalkley |
| 2014 | Bryce Chalkley |
U - Unanimous Selection
C - Consensus Selection
Y - Academic All-American of the Year